Why Your Business Needs Commercial Umbrella Insurance (And What Happens If You Don’t Have It)

The Hanover Insurance Group estimates that nearly 80% of businesses are not adequately covered against potentially business-ending lawsuits and catastrophic losses. This is not because business owners are reckless - it is because standard liability policies have limits, and those limits are often exceeded by serious claims before business owners realize the gap.

Commercial umbrella insurance is one of the most cost-effective protections available to Texas businesses. A $1 million umbrella policy typically costs $40–$75 per month. A single catastrophic liability claim without umbrella coverage can cost your business everything above your primary policy limit - equipment, savings, and in some cases, personal assets. Here is what you need to know, and how to determine if your business is one of the majority that is underprotected.

---

What Is Commercial Umbrella Insurance?

Commercial umbrella insurance is a supplemental liability policy that activates when a covered claim exceeds the limits of your primary liability policies. It does not replace your primary policies - it extends them. Think of it as a financial backstop that prevents one large claim from costing your business more than your primary coverage can pay.

It is important to understand the trigger: commercial umbrella coverage only activates after your primary liability policy pays its full limit on a covered claim. If your general liability policy has a $1 million per-occurrence limit and a covered claim comes in at $2.2 million, your umbrella policy pays the $1.2 million above the primary limit, up to the umbrella’s limit.

Umbrella vs. Excess Liability Insurance

These two terms are frequently confused. Excess liability insurance extends the limits of a single specified underlying policy. Commercial umbrella insurance extends the limits of multiple underlying policies simultaneously - general liability, commercial auto liability, and employer’s liability from a workers’ compensation policy - with one umbrella policy rather than purchasing higher limits on each individual policy. This makes commercial umbrella significantly more cost-efficient than raising limits on each policy separately.

---

What Does Commercial Umbrella Insurance Cover?

A commercial umbrella policy provides additional coverage limits for claims already covered under your underlying liability policies. Specifically, it extends coverage for:

• Bodily injury: Medical expenses, lost wages, and legal fees if a third party is injured due to your business operations. A serious customer slip-and-fall, a contractor accident, or a delivery vehicle collision that causes significant injuries can generate claims well above standard liability limits.

• Property damage: Repair or replacement costs if your business or employees damage a third party’s property. A contractor who accidentally damages a client’s building, or an employee who causes significant property damage during service delivery, are typical scenarios.

• Personal and advertising injury: Libel, slander, copyright infringement, and similar claims, where covered under the underlying general liability policy.

• Commercial auto liability: Legal costs and damages from accidents involving company vehicles that exceed your commercial auto policy’s liability limits.

• Employer’s liability: Claims from employees who sue outside the workers’ compensation system for employer negligence, where your WC policy’s employer’s liability limit is exceeded.

---

What Commercial Umbrella Insurance Does NOT Cover

Understanding the exclusions is as important as understanding the coverage. Commercial umbrella insurance does not cover:

• Your own property damage: Commercial umbrella is a liability coverage extension. It does not cover damage to your own building, equipment, or inventory. Property losses are handled by your commercial property policy.

• Professional liability / errors and omissions: Claims of professional negligence, bad advice, or failure to perform are not covered by commercial umbrella. To increase protection in this area, the limits on your professional liability (E&O) policy itself must be raised.

• Intentional acts: Deliberate harm or misconduct by you or your employees is not covered.

• Workers’ compensation: The medical benefits and wage replacement portions of workers’ comp claims are not extended by umbrella. Umbrella may extend the employer’s liability portion in some policies, but this varies.

• Excluded perils from primary policies: If a type of claim is excluded from your underlying liability policy, umbrella insurance does not add coverage for it. Umbrella extends limits, not coverage categories.

---

Real-World Scenarios Where Commercial Umbrella Makes the Difference

The value of commercial umbrella coverage is easiest to understand through examples of the types of claims it is designed to address.

Scenario 1: Serious Slip-and-Fall at a Retail Business

A customer enters your Dallas retail store on a wet floor and falls, suffering a severe head injury requiring surgery and extended rehabilitation. Total medical costs, lost wages, and pain-and-suffering damages reach $1.8 million. Your general liability policy has a $1 million per-occurrence limit. Without umbrella coverage, your business owes $800,000 above your coverage limit - payable from your business assets or, in some structures, personal assets. A $2 million umbrella policy would have covered the full excess.

Scenario 2: Commercial Vehicle Accident

One of your employees is involved in a serious multi-vehicle accident while making a delivery. Multiple parties are injured, and property damage is significant. Total liability reaches $2.5 million. Your commercial auto policy has a $1 million liability limit. Without umbrella, your business faces $1.5 million above your coverage limit. An umbrella policy with $2 million in coverage would have fully protected your business.

Scenario 3: Contractor Property Damage

A contractor working on a large commercial renovation project makes an error that results in significant structural damage to the client’s building. The repair cost plus business interruption losses claimed by the client total $1.7 million. The contractor’s general liability policy has a $1 million per-occurrence limit. Without umbrella coverage, the contractor absorbs $700,000 in uncovered losses.

Scenario 4: Contract Requirement

A growing DFW service business wins a contract with a large corporate client. The contract requires $3 million in general liability coverage per occurrence. The business’s current general liability policy has a $1 million limit. Rather than replacing the policy with a $3 million limit - which would be significantly more expensive - the business adds a $2 million commercial umbrella policy at a fraction of the cost, meeting the contract requirement and enabling the deal to proceed.

---

Who Needs Commercial Umbrella Insurance Most?

While virtually any business can benefit from umbrella coverage, some business types have higher exposure that makes it a near-necessity rather than an option.

• Restaurants, bars, and food service businesses: High customer traffic, alcohol liability exposure, and slip-and-fall risk in kitchen and dining environments create above-average liability frequency. See our restaurant insurance page for industry-specific guidance.

• Contractors and construction businesses: Work site accidents, property damage to clients, and subcontractor liability issues regularly generate claims above standard policy limits. Contract requirements for higher limits are also common in the construction industry.

• Businesses with company vehicles: Any business with employees who drive company or personal vehicles for business purposes faces commercial auto liability exposure. Multi-vehicle accidents can quickly exceed $1 million in liability.

• Retail stores, gyms, and venues with significant foot traffic: Physical customer presence creates ongoing slip-and-fall, injury, and premises liability exposure.

• Businesses with large corporate clients or government contracts: Contract-mandated liability minimums of $2–$5 million per occurrence are common with larger clients and government work.

• Any business with significant assets to protect: The more your business (and personal assets, in some structures) have accumulated, the more there is at stake in a catastrophic liability claim.

---

How Much Does Commercial Umbrella Insurance Cost?

Commercial umbrella insurance is priced in $1 million coverage increments. Each increment costs approximately $40–$75 per month for most small businesses, depending on your industry, revenue, claims history, and the underlying policies it supplements. Insureon reports an average cost of $75 per month - or $900 annually - for umbrella coverage among small businesses.

Consider that context: $75 per month for $1–2 million in additional liability protection above your current limits. For comparison, a single serious liability claim that exceeds your current limits by $1 million would cost your business 1,000 months of umbrella premium to absorb out of pocket. The math on umbrella coverage is straightforward for most businesses.

Important: Commercial umbrella is not a standalone policy. You must carry the underlying liability policies (general liability, commercial auto) before umbrella coverage can be added. Your underlying policies must also meet minimum required limits set by the umbrella carrier.

---

How to Get Commercial Umbrella Coverage for Your Texas Business

Thumann Insurance Agency reviews your current commercial liability policy structure and determines the right umbrella coverage amount for your industry and risk profile. Because we work with 80+ carriers, we can compare umbrella options across the full market to find the best combination of coverage and price. If you have existing underlying policies with any carrier, commercial umbrella insurance can often be layered on regardless of where those policies are held.

Call (972) 991-9100 or request a commercial insurance quote to review your liability coverage today.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Is commercial umbrella insurance required by law in Texas?

No. Texas law does not require commercial umbrella insurance. However, many contracts with clients, landlords, and government agencies require businesses to carry liability limits that exceed standard policy limits - making umbrella coverage contractually required for those relationships, if not legally required by the state.

Can commercial umbrella insurance extend the limits on my commercial auto policy?

Yes. One of the key advantages of commercial umbrella over excess liability is that it extends limits across multiple underlying policies simultaneously - including commercial auto liability - rather than applying to only one policy.

Does commercial umbrella insurance cover professional liability claims?

No. Commercial umbrella does not extend professional liability (errors and omissions) coverage. If you need higher limits on a professional liability policy, the limits on that policy itself must be increased.

What is the minimum general liability limit required to get a commercial umbrella policy?

Most umbrella carriers require underlying general liability policies to have at least $300,000–$1 million per occurrence in coverage. Your broker can confirm whether your current underlying limits meet the umbrella carrier’s requirements.